1. Home
  2. Community
  3. Hoisted on their own

Hoisted on their own


Hoisted on their own petard…[i]

Hegel once said, “The only thing we learn from history is that we never learn from history.”[ii] Now, not even short-term history – like last year! This election season, no one seems to remember that less than a year ago, Insurance Companies were jacking rates up as much as 25% – this time just before the mid-term elections…and by about the same amount, allegedly to ‘pay for health reform.’ A Fact that is angering voters who were promised repeatedly by President Barack Obama that health reform would save families $2,500 a year by 2013.

Republicans are vowing to undo many of the items in the bill or simply cut off funding if they assume power in the House and Senate. For all the GOP chest-thumping about reversing the new health care law, a full repeal, to put it generously, is a long-term project. Even if they retake the House this November, they almost certainly won’t retake the Senate. Even if they retake both the House and the Senate, they’d still have to contend with a Democratic filibuster (for a change). And even if the filibuster weren’t an issue, they’d still have to contend with a Presidential veto. This adds up to long odds, and they know it.

But that doesn’t mean they can do no harm. How? By using  Congress’ prerogative to appropriate funds as a key tool if they win back the House.  And that’s not just bluster.This is the most serious, yet realistic, possibility for the Republicans if they win a majority in the House. It can work one of few ways:

1) House Republicans could demand appropriation levels beneath what’s necessary to effectively implement the law. They could cut the funding 10 or even 20% – and that could do a lot of damage, yet Obama would be hard pressed to issue a veto.

2) Republicans could simply refuse to fund the entire Labor-HHS appropriations bill.

3) Republicans could pass an appropriation for Labor-HHS that does not include any funds for implementation of the Affordable Care Act, which would lead to a presidential veto and a showdown between the White House and Congress.

All of this means that Republicans could be hoisted on their own petard! They have not put together any plans to get people health insurance  – and the Census Bureau says that the ranks of the uninsured 30% last year, to 50,000,000 people. If they prevent implementation, many middle class families will lose their consumer protections.

The big problem is that the changes began implementation last Thursday (9/30/10), and despite widespread confusion, the benefits are extremely popular with voters. A Republican push to repeal the bill could spell big trouble for candidates in 2012. Voters already feel taken advantage of by health insurance companies and if Republicans are successful in their stalling attempts, then even more people will become uninsured.

Read more: http://www.modbee.com/2010/10/03/1366323/health-insurance-reform-means.html#ixzz11P9FV9jw

[i] Shakespeare, specifically Hamlet, act III, scene 4, lines 206 and 207. A petard is
a small explosive device designed to blow open barricaded doors, gates and
persons. The petard was a favorite weapon in Elizabethan times.

[ii] Quoted in James Christian. Philosophy: Introduction to the Art of Wondering. 2009 Wadsworth Cengage Learning (Belmont CA) p. 306

The views and opinions expressed by Perspectives contributors are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or recommendations of the American Nurses Association, the Editorial Advisory Board members, or the Publisher, Editors and staff of American Nurse Journal. These are opinion pieces and are not peer reviewed.

6 Comments. Leave new

  • It is a shame that once again those without will suffer. We as nurses have encountered someone that couldn’t afford their medicines or their copay and their health suffered. If a repeal does occur, I suggest that those in Congress go without also. To truly represent one must walk in the same shoes.

  • Louise Moondancer
    October 24, 2010 11:16 pm

    Does anyone care..there are real people here that will suffer. We claim to be a caring and compassionate people but we sit by and heartlessly watch people suffer and die unnecessarily. Politics be damned…we need leadership with courage and conviction that is more concerned about the people they serve than about their own election.

  • I am getting pretty tired of the huge division between the two parties. It is juvenile to continue this fighting and pointing fingers when our nation is in a crisis. The Democrates as well as the Republicians are all a bunch of imoral, greedy, out for me type of people. Our nation needs unity and all I see is fighting among us which in turn makes us a very weak nation. It is time to stand up and do the job right on all accounts, not just health reform.

  • If Congress fails to fund the ‘Affordable Care Act’ – or refuses to fund it suffiently, it will be health providers who will be ‘hoisted on that petard’!

  • You use the words ‘health insurance reform’ instead of ‘health reform’…what’s the difference so far as most of us are concerned?

  • …What is scary is that Congress can give and take away benefits within a year! Goes to show that you cannot trust government!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

cheryl meeGet your free access to the exclusive newsletter of American Nurse Journal and gain insights for your nursing practice.

NurseLine Newsletter

  • Hidden

*By submitting your e-mail, you are opting in to receiving information from Healthcom Media and Affiliates. The details, including your email address/mobile number, may be used to keep you informed about future products and services.


More Perspectives