Mentoring in the age of new nursing

Author(s): Theresa Brown, BSN, RN, FAAN

My first job in nursing was on a medical oncology floor where there was a lot of bullying. I was a new nurse so I didn’t know that bullying among nurses is common. I told this story in my first book, Critical Care, but it’s worth telling again in the context of discussing mentoring.

That medical oncology floor was an extreme example of what I’m calling “old nursing.” Two clinicians—essentially assistant managers—ran the floor by yelling at staff and selectively and harshly enforcing rules. I’m retelling this story here because there were times when I felt so defeated by the bullying on the floor that I thought about leaving nursing. I had gone back to school after getting a PhD in English, made my way through chemistry, genetics, and anatomy and physiology, and then completed the University of Pittsburgh’s one-year accelerated nursing program. I considered abandoning all of that because I had grown to hate my job, and no one told me a new nursing job might be very different.

However, I finally figured out that I needed to abandon that particular hospital floor, not nursing, and transferred to another medical oncology floor. The nurses on my new floor focused on the patients and the job, not on puffing themselves up by putting others down. I loved the work, and stayed in nursing.

The contrast between these two floors reflects the difference between old nursing and my aspirational definition of new nursing, and that difference can be applied to the idea of mentoring new hires. I’ve never had a clinical job with any kind of mentoring program, but I can imagine one. New nursing would build in mentoring for every new hire for a set period of time. Mentors could be other nurses on the floor, or nurses working on several different floors who are specially trained to help new nurses adjust. Mentoring is different from supervision. It involves giving new nurse hires the clinical and emotional support they need to succeed in the job.

Alternatively, mentoring could involve a supportive boost at the start of a job. On a tour of the Cleveland Clinic a few years ago I saw one possible model for this idea. New hires with clinical deficits were given an extra week of orientation doing focused work in the simulation lab. The simulations were designed to elevate their clinical skills to the level of a typical graduate nurse, and the extra simulation training was not seen as punitive, but as helpful.

The phrase “nurses eat their young” needs to be retired as a relic of old nursing, as does nurse-on-nurse bullying. New nursing emphasizes teamwork and that we all succeed together. Whatever form it takes, mentoring embraces the value in new hires, and works hard to keep them on as long-term members of the health care team.

Theresa Brown, BSN, RN, FAAN, is Clinical Faculty at the University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing. Her most recent book, The Shift: One Nurse, Twelve Hours, Four Patients’ Lives, was a New York Times bestseller.

She is a frequent contributor to the New York Times and also writes for CNN.com. She has been interviewed on the NPR program “Fresh Air,” and has appeared on “Hardball,” and MSNBC live.

Brown writes and speaks about nursing, health care and end of life care. She has a PhD in English from the University of Chicago. Her kids inspired her to leave academia and pursue nursing. It is a career change she has never regretted.

Please visit Theresa’s website, TheresaBrownRN.com, and on Twitter at @TheresaBrown.

2 COMMENTS

  1. I started in critical care, and ended up leaving the floor and hospital all together because of bullying. I had no where to turn to, including management. I cried for WEEKS before finally going to a new hospital where I found all the support I needed to do well.

  2. Thank you for writing this article. I have recently gone back to school to pursue a career in nursing. I’m currently a waiter/bartender and last night a couple whose son is a nurse shared that same phrase with me: “Nurses eat their young.” They also mentioned that because I am a male I would be in the minority and I would be more susceptible to being bullied. Your article gives me hope for a better experience.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here